Supreme Court’s verdict on Asghar Khan Case is being used by a section
of unconscionable media men, palmed off anchorpersons, analysts and
panelists who have started propaganda blitz against the Armed Forces and
the ISI.
In the name of freedom of speech, they comment on the role of
some retired generals in politics for five decades after independence,
and in the process target the Army as an institution. Their aim is to
tarnish the image of Armed Forces/ISI arguably at the behest of enemies
of Pakistan, as defaming the military is the first phase of their
sinister plan to weaken Pakistan. And in case they succeed in their
nefarious designs, we all stand to suffer. One anchorperson of a
renowned private
TV channel, who
is also columnist, has spewed venom against Pakistan military in his
column in Urdu daily on 12th November, drawing parallelism with recent
ouster of CIA Chief David Patreaus. He stooped so low as to cast
aspersions on the defenders of the frontiers and resorted to unwarranted
criticism.
Another anchorperson known for his malicious intent
against military tried to poison the minds of the people alleging that
recent firing incident on his residence was the act of intelligence
agencies. In fact, it was an effort to improve the dwindling rating of his
program
that he resorted to cheap tactics and concocted this story. Just watch
the comments in print and electronic media about General (r) Aslam Beg
and General (r) Asad Durrani for having distributed money among some
politicians, and you can observe that military and the ISI are under
attack. If in the past some military adventurers had imposed Martial
Law, the present military leadership is not to blame, just like the
present judiciary cannot be blamed or held responsible for members of
judiciary that had given legitimacy to the military dictators. The fact
of the matter is that our political parties and leaders have been
accusing each other of corruption and for supporting the military
dictators in the past.
It was due to the conflict between the
political parties, intolerance and deep-rooted hatred among politicians
in the past that provided opportunity to
the Generals
to intervene. In 1977, it was Pakistan National Alliance (PNA) that had
started agitation against Bhutto government on the plea that it had
rigged elections. Before October 1958 Martial Law also, political
parties were at loggerheads. As regards former General Pervez
Musharraf’s military dispensation, the Grand Democratic Alliance was
formed on one-point i.e. to get rid of Nawaz government. Almost all
political and
religious parties
and their leaders have at one time or another aided and abetted military
dictators and joined their bandwagons. Those leaders who were propped
up by the military to become heads of the state often criticized
military more than others. Anyhow, no political party could boast about
its democratic credentials or impeccable character of its leaders.
Even
judiciary had provided legitimacy to the military dictators and allowed
dictators to amend the constitution, which right judiciary itself did
not have. During the last 65 years, Pakistan has faced multi-faceted
crisis, and once suffered the trauma of disintegration. Of course, one
should not hold brief for the military dictator, but keeping in view the
conduct of the present military leadership, the scathing criticism is
unwarranted. Perhaps there is some link between Col (r) Inam’s petition
and the column published on 12th November 2012. The question also arises
why Col (r) Inam filed the petition in 2012 when the extension was
given in 2010, and why he has chosen to pursue the case at this point in
time when the media is highlighting the clash between the institutions.
In fact, there was nothing wrong what COAS had said about abiding by
the Constitution. The question can also be asked whether the army chief
does not enjoy the same right as citizen of Pakistan.
There are quite a few
countries
in the world that were once ruled by kings, dictators and had military
dispensations or Martial Laws but nowhere in the world have they heaped
insult on their armed forces. Anyhow, since the commencement of judicial
proceedings on the Mehrangate, a public debate had been triggered off.
It was fundamentally flawed, as both the commentriat and the media men
had it that devil in the scam was the military and the ISI. However, the
apex court in its verdict on Asghar Khan Case categorically stated that
two generals had acted in their personal capacity and the institution
of military was not involved. Some fanatics and vested interest are also
trying to take advantage of the impression that there is confrontation
between Military and Judiciary. Col (r) Inam-ur-Rahim, petitioner
against 3-year extension to COAS Ashfaq Parvez Kayani in Islamabad High
Court, and counsel for Brigadier Ali Khan who is facing Court Martial,
was allegedly beaten up in Rawalpindi the other day.
He has submitted an
application
in R.A. Bazar police station Rawalpindi for registration of FIR against
COAS Ashfaq Parvez Kayani and DG Military Intelligence Major General
Naushad Kayani. Col (r) Inam claims to be convener of Ex-servicemen
Society. However, the secretary of the society has taken exception to
the news in the media indicating that he was convener of the society. In
a
press release, the society has
disowned him, adding that there is no slot of a convener in the
organization. The matter has to be investigated whether he has been
beaten up due to some personal enmity or
family feud.
He appears to be playing into the hands of some media men who are also
using his name to defame the armed forces and intelligence agencies. On
24th September 2012, Islamabad High Court had rejected his petition
against the extension of service to COAS Ashfaq Parvez Kayani, declaring
it non-maintainable. On 12th November, he filed a miscellaneous
petition in Islamabad High Court against recent
statement of COAS, arguing that General Kayani was not entitled to remain in
Office after making a political statement. Who is behind him and the journalists who denigrate armed forces?
—The
writer is Lahore-based senior journalist.