Balochistan issue has been in the highlights for the past couple of
months now. Why is Balochistan being given so much importance?
Why is it
so important for us to find a solution to this problem now? How the
issue of Balochistan can be resolved? These are a few typical questions
which cross the minds of a common Pakistani when they see a bulletin or a
talk show on Balochistan.Balochistan-though being the largest province
of Pakistan-is yet the most backward and underdeveloped of all. Although
at present the separatist elements of the ongoing insurgency in
Balochistan do not enjoy absolute support amongst the Baloch population
of Pakistan yet the feeling of resentment and the grievances are growing
with each passing day.
The main factors responsible for this feeling of resentment are the
alienation of Baloch people from the main stream politics, the
socio-economic underdevelopment, the issue of the ownership of
resources, the due share of the Baloch people in the benefits of their
own resources and the unfortunate underrepresentation of Baloch in the
civil-military bureaucracy at national level.
To add to all of these grievances has been the frequent use of brute
force by the military, the non-committed and non-serious attitude of the
political leadership towards the resolution of Baloch issues. The ‘kill
and dump’ strategy adopted by the intelligence agencies and the
paramilitary forces to counter the recent wave of insurgency has done
nothing but aggravated the whole situation. As Habib Jalib has once
said:
You are sowing love with bullets,
And washing country’s face with blood,
While you are busy justifying the means…
I am sure that you are losing the end!
One of the many factors behind socio-economic backwardness of
Balochistan is the tribal structure of its society. Since the time of
British rule, the tribal chieftains have been in a partnership with the
country’s ruling elite; the Sarkar and the Sardars have joined hands at
the expense of the common Baloch people.
The solution of the Balochistan issue lies in dedicated political
will and a pragmatic approach with both long and short term means to
address the root causes of the insurgency and to gradually transform the
conflict. Political dialogue with all the major stake holders of
Balochistan is imperative in order to resolve the issue. However a
combination of different CBMs is a prerequisite to bring these
stakeholders to table talks.
An effective solution to the missing persons issue and an immediate stop
to the ‘kill and dump’ policy would be the first milestone towards
confidence building amongst the people of Balochistan.
Secondly the perpetrators of Human Rights violation shall be brought
before law and justice on effective and immediate basis in order to
reinstate the lost trust of a common man in institutions of state.
These steps would ensure law and order in the province and would have a positive impact on the entire society.
Establishing a task force aimed at transforming the protracted
conflict comes under the umbrella of the long term approaches. The task
force shall be invested with power and capacity of monitoring the
effective implementation of constitutional reforms and the management of
development projects like Gwadar, SANDAK, REKODICK, along with
construction of dams, roads and other infrastructure, and shall put
these projects on a fast track. These developmental endeavors could
bring about a change in the tribal system of Balochistan only if the
local people are a part and parcel of such projects. Being employed
would allow the local common Baloch to become financially independent
relinquishing their dependence on Sardars who have been so far
controlling their fates.
The development activities along with continuation of the democratic
setup, preservation of the parliamentary and federal structure of
Pakistan and re-shaping the foreign policy would help amongst other
factors to transform the conflict gradually over time. The political
leadership and establishment must ensure participation of all the
nationalist parties in Balochistan in the upcoming polls along with a
promise of free and fair elections. Democracy is crucial for sustenance
of the federal structure of Pakistan and strengthening of the federating
units. The policy of supporting and encouraging any sort of
destabilizing elements and forces across the border must be reviewed,
reconsidered and redefined by keeping in view the national interest of
Pakistan.
The counter insurgency strategy must be based upon ‘carrot and stick’
formula. The insurgent elements with secessionist tendencies must be
dealt with might and force however there is a need to ensure that the
just grievances of the rest of the Baloch people have not been left
unaddressed. Otherwise the distressed Baloch masses would not hesitate
in joining the ranks of insurgent organizations if they are not given
any rightful alternative to get their demands fulfilled.
It is time for the civil and military leadership sitting in Islamabad
to realize that military might alone will do nothing good except for
pushing the Baloch nationalists over the edge towards the demands of
independence, and that is the least what Pakistan would want considering
its survival and national interest would be at stake.
Hence this time the need is to mainly change the approach of looking
at the Balochistan issue; the need is to change the typical colonial
mindset and to go for a different way to address the issues at hand.